17.4.2 Musical Instruments

An important application of standing waves is to musical instruments. Instruments such as the guitar, the piano, and the violin have strings fixed at the ends and tightened to create tension. A disturbance generated on the string by plucking, striking, or bowing it creates a standing wave on the string.

The fundamental frequency of a vibrating string is

f1=v2L=12LTsμ

where Ts is the tension in the string and μ is its linear density. The fundamental frequency is the musical note you hear when the string is sounded. Increasing the tension in the string raises the fundamental frequency, which is how stringed instruments are tuned.

NOTE   v is the wave speed on the string, not the speed of sound in air.

For the guitar or the violin, the strings are all the same length and under approximately the same tension. Were that not the case, the neck of the instrument would tend to twist toward the side of higher tension. The strings have different frequencies because they differ in linear density: The lower-pitched strings are “fat” while the higher-pitched strings are “skinny.” This difference changes the frequency by changing the wave speed. Small adjustments are then made in the tension to bring each string to the exact desired frequency. Once the instrument is tuned, you play it by using your fingertips to alter the effective length of the string. As you shorten the string’s length, the frequency and pitch go up.

A piano covers a much wider range of frequencies than a guitar or violin. This range cannot be produced by changing only the linear densities of the strings. The high end would have strings too thin to use without breaking, and the low end would have solid rods rather than flexible wires! So a piano is tuned through a combination of changing the linear density and the length of the strings. The bass note strings are not only fatter, they are also longer.

A photograph of a person playing the harp.

The strings on a harp vibrate as standing waves. Their frequencies determine the notes that you hear.

With a wind instrument, blowing into the mouthpiece creates a standing sound wave inside a tube of air. The player changes the notes by using her fingers to cover holes or open valves, changing the length of the tube and thus its frequency. The fact that the holes are on the side makes very little difference; the first open hole becomes an antinode because the air is free to oscillate in and out of the opening.

A wind instrument’s frequency depends on the speed of sound inside the instrument. But the speed of sound depends on the temperature of the air. When a wind player first blows into the instrument, the air inside starts to rise in temperature. This increases the sound speed, which in turn raises the instrument’s frequency for each note until the air temperature reaches a steady state. Consequently, wind players must “warm up” before tuning their instrument.

Many wind instruments have a “buzzer” at one end of the tube, such as a vibrating reed on a saxophone or vibrating lips on a trombone. Buzzers generate a continuous range of frequencies rather than single notes, which is why they sound like a “squawk” if you play on just the mouthpiece without the rest of the instrument. When a buzzer is connected to the body of the instrument, most of those frequencies cause no response of the air molecules. But the frequency from the buzzer that matches the fundamental frequency of the instrument causes the buildup of a large-amplitude response at just that frequency—a standing-wave resonance. This is the energy input that generates and sustains the musical note.

EXAMPLE 17.6 Flutes and clarinets

A clarinet is 66.0 cm long. A flute is nearly the same length, with 63.6 cm between the hole the player blows across and the end of the flute. What are the frequencies of the lowest note and the next higher harmonic on a flute and on a clarinet? The speed of sound in warm air is 350 m/s.

MODEL The flute is an open-open tube, open at the end as well as at the hole the player blows across. A clarinet is an open-closed tube because the player’s lips and the reed seal the tube at the upper end.

SOLVE The lowest frequency is the fundamental frequency. For the flute, an open-open tube, this is

f1=v2L=350 m/s2(0.636 m)=275 Hz

The clarinet, an open-closed tube, has

f1=v4L=350 m/s4(0.660 m)=133 Hz

The next higher harmonic on the flute’s open-open tube is m=2 with frequency f2=2 f1=550 Hz. An open-closed tube has only odd harmonics, so the next higher harmonic of the clarinet is f3=3 f1=399 Hz.

REVIEW The clarinet plays a much lower note than the flute—musically, about an octave lower—because it is an open-closed tube. It’s worth noting that neither of our fundamental frequencies is exactly correct because our open-open and open-closed tube models are a bit too simplified to adequately describe a real instrument. However, both calculated frequencies are close because our models do capture the essence of the physics.

A vibrating string plays the musical note corresponding to the fundamental frequency f1, so stringed instruments must use several strings to obtain a reasonable range of notes. In contrast, wind instruments can sound at the second or third harmonic of the tube of air (f2 or f3). These higher frequencies are sounded by overblowing (flutes, brass instruments) or with keys that open small holes to encourage the formation of an antinode at that point (clarinets, saxophones). The controlled use of these higher harmonics gives wind instruments a wide range of notes.